Lorenzo and I are beginning to add some instructor comments on the rough drafts.

Please note:

1. Authors: Your peer reviewers have more time to comment on your drafts than we do.  Our comments will be brief, but there is much to learn from your peer reviewers' comments.

2. Authors: If we say a section is "fine", that just means there are no glaring errors.  Your peer reviewers will probably have suggestions for you that will make that section even better than "just fine".

3. Peer reviewers: in some cases we will be commenting on a paper before you get to writing your peer review for it.  We don't have time to write much on each paper, so if we say a section is "fine", it just means there are no glaring errors.  The author will still benefit from your more detailed and thoughtful suggestion about something they can improve in that section, and about something they did well in the section. 

all best,

-BJ