F: Parking Meters At CMU


Section 1: Introduction                            18/20

  GREAT EXCEPT FOR SOME ISSUES WITH REFERENCES/CITATIONS

  Research Question and Motivation

  Citations to literature on this topic

  Quick summary of main results from Section 4

Section 2: Methods                                  19/20

NICE JOB.  

  Target population, frame, sample design/methods, sample size

  Number of respondents contacted, number of respondents, other
  nonresponse/refusal information

  A few questions from your questionnaire (full questionnaire, contact
  letter(s), informed consent statement, etc, in appendices)

  Post-survey processing

  Other relevant information from the body of your progress report
  talk

Section 3: Results                                  15/20

  YOU COMPREHENSIVELY LOOKED AT MANY THINGS AND MANY RELATIONSHIPS.
  THAT WAS GOOD.

  IN THE SIMPLE COUNTS AND PERCENTS YOU COULD & SHOULD HAVE PROVIDED
  STD ERRORS BASED ON REPLICATING THE CENSUS 10 TIMES.

  THE REGRESSION ANALYSES DELETED OVER HALF YOUR DATA!  NEED TO RUN
  ON CLEANED-UP DATA FROM POST-SURVEY PROCESSING, OR HAVE A VERY GOOD
  EXPLANATION ABOUT WHY IT IS OK TO DELETE SO MANY CASES.

  (may or may not be longer than Section 2!)

  Restate research question(s), show statistical analyses, discuss how
  they answer each research question (gory stat details in another
  appendix?)

Section 4: Discussion                               20/20

  LOOKS GREAT.  

  Overall discussion of research questions, how well survey answered
  them

  Any surprising, or expected, results

  Strengths and weaknesses of your survey; recommendations for future

  Take-home message(s)

List of References                                  7/10

Appendices                                          10/10

TOTAL                                               89/100

====================================================================