Team G			97/100

CHOI, ERICA JIYOUNG       Senior CMU SHS  L     9.0  ejchoi  
GARG, AIENA               Junior HSS STA  L     9.0  aienag  
KIM, DONG SEOB            Senior MCS CMY  L     9.0  dongseok 
SHOUP, JOHN A.            Soph   HSS H00  L     9.0  johnshou 
CHO, HYE JUNG             Junior HSS STA  L     9.0  hyejungc

OVERALL:

Either project will be fine to do.  Please let me know in email which
one you will choose.


1. Faculty Attitudes Toward Plus/Minus Grading at CMU

   A. Interest.	     	    10/10

      I like that you have refocused the survey on faculty rather
      than students.

      [don't forget to change the title of your survey accordingly]

   B. Research Questions.	10/10

      ok

   C. References.	     5/5

      ok
      
   D. Sampling Frame		7/8

      ok.  what sort of list will you sample faculty from (be
      specific!)?

      also, it is probably a good idea to focus on the CMU campus only

   E. Target Population		7/8

      ok.  see D. above also 

   F. Mode of Data Collection	5/5

      good to use face to face as a followup for nonresponders.

   G. Important Variables	4/4

      ok

2. General Attitude/Behavior on Online Shopping by CMU Students

   A. Interest.		     	10/10

      nice that you have shifted to a "products" orientation.
      
   B. Research Questions.	10/10

      ok

   C. References.		5/5

      fine


   D. Sampling Frame		8/8

      ok.  I can see from E that you really mean the sampling frame to
      be C-book, which is fine.  

   E. Target Population		7/8

      since your frame only covers CMU, it makes more sense to make
      the target population be just  CMU students.

   F. Mode of Data Collection5/5

      ok

   G. Important Variables	4/4

      ok