Team F		    91/100

DAUGHTREY, ABIGAIL S.     Soph   HSS ENG  L     9.0  adaughtr
LONCKE, CHRISTOPHER       Senior MCS MSC  L     9.0  cloncke  
MIKHAEL, BASSEM           Senior CMU SHS  L     9.0  bmikhael 
Choi, Yong-Gyun		  	     	  	     yonggyuc
AGARWAL, PRERNA PRADEEP   Senior HSS ECO  L     9.0  ppagarwa 

OVERALL:

(a) You are free to choose either survey.  Let me know which one you
prefer.  

(b) I don't see any evidence that Yong-Gyun is involved in your group.


1. Student Consumption and Perception of Caffeine Consumption on
   Campus

   A. Interest.		7/10

      ok

   B. Research Questions.  	 10/10

      good set of questions

   C. References.	5/5

      ok

   D. Sampling Frame		8/8

      ok

   E. Target Population		8/8

      ok.  good discussion of opt-out

   F. Mode of Data Collection	5/5

      ok

   G. Important Variables	4/4

      ok

2. World Geography Knowledge: CMU vs Average Pittsburgh Residents

   A. Interest.	   	      7/10

      ok
      
   B. Research Questions.	10/10

      I like the idea of comparing knowledge with perceived importance
      (items c, d).


   C. References.	5/5

      OK

   D. Sampling Frame		6/8

      ok description of sampling procedure (since there is no
      frame). One important idea to keep in mind, is that you should
      have a fixed plan for selecting people who walk by the booths
      (for example, always approach every 3rd person).  Otherwise you
      will be more vulnerable to selection biases (yours, in terms of
      who you would prefer to talk to, and the respondents', in terms
      of who is more likely to take or more interested in taking, yuor
      survey).

   E. Target Population		7/8

      correct that you really have two populations to work with.  For
      each population, you will need to check that your sample is
      similar to a random sample (e.g. contains proportions of various
      demographic groups similar to that in CMU's factbook, or in
      similar publications about the city.

   F. Mode of Data Collection	5/5

      you may not need on-campus booths if you will be using
      email/surveymonkey to collect cmu student responses.

   G. Important Variables	4/4

      ok