Team E		85/100

HIGGINS, TIMOTHY PATRICK  Senior CMU SHS  L     9.0  thiggins
BELENKY, MATTHEW          Senior HSS ECO  L     9.0  mbelenky
SPERGER, JOHN H           Senior HSS SDS  L     9.0  jsperger 
WU, TIAN                  Junior TSB BA   L     9.0  tianw    
WANG, CHAO                Junior CIT ECE  L     9.0  chaowang 

1. A survey of CMU Student Exercise Habits

   A. Interest.	   	   15/20

      Possibly interesting.  Note that a previous 303 survey focused
      on use of the UC's facilities so I like the idea of looking at
      exercise more broadly.  

      No references or examples to back up claims: "exercise is
      ignored by the university", "college has a rep of poor athletics
      and out of shape students", etc.

      Make a stronger case that this survey is necessary!

   B. Research Questions.	  15/20

      good start.  Additionally might ask about how motivated the
      respondent is, to exercise, and about anything that makes it
      easier or harder to exercise (time, location, avail of certain
      types of equipment / services / facilities, etc.)


   C. References.		5/10

      No references on CMU exercise habits?

      Missing one reference (matt?)

2. Accuracy of Pittsburgh Bus Schedules around Carnegie Mellon

   A. Interest.		      20/20

      This has some interest for students using buses, and for PAT
      (the city transit authority).  

      It's not clear if you intend to survey people to find their
      perceptions of bus schedule accuracy, or survey buses
      (i.e. stand at bus stops, measure arrival times, and compare
      with published schedule.

      I actually like surveying buses, bus stops, etc., for this,
      better than surveying people.

      Perhaps you could add a small sample of people to get some
      perception information, after you have done the bus/bus-stop
      survey. 

   B. Research Questions.	20/20

      This is a good initial set of questions, especially if you are
      surveying buses/bus-stops.

   C. References.	10/10

      good set of references to start.